Neighborhood Guide

Sheepshead Bay

Sheepshead Bay Listings

3 BR at 5 CANDA AVE, #-

Exclusive

5 CANDA AVE, #-
Apartment • Sheepshead Bay
$675,000
3 BR | 2 BT
1 BR at 2241 PLUMB 1ST STREET, #1N

RLS

2241 PLUMB 1ST STREET, #1N
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$190,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Keller Williams Realty Empire
1 BR at 7 LAKE AVENUE

RLS

7 LAKE AVENUE
Townhouse • Sheepshead Bay
$330,000
1 FM | 1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Revived Residential
Studio at 1717 EAST 18TH STREET, #3K

RLS

1717 EAST 18TH STREET, #3K
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$220,000
Studio | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Weichert Properties
3 BR at 1733 EAST 14TH STREET, #D

RLS

1733 EAST 14TH STREET, #D
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$750,000
3 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Keller Williams NYC
4 BR at 3086 AVENUE WEST

RLS

3086 AVENUE WEST
Townhouse • Sheepshead Bay
$825,000
2 FM | 4 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Revived Residential
2 BR at 2652 EAST 18TH STREET, #2A

RLS

2652 EAST 18TH STREET, #2A
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$805,000
2 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass
4 BR at 4653 BEDFORD AVENUE

RLS

4653 BEDFORD AVENUE
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$5,900
4 BR | 2.5 BT

Listing Courtesy Of POLJAN PROPERTIES INC
2 BR at 1844 EAST 12TH STREET, #3

RLS

1844 EAST 12TH STREET, #3
Townhouse • Sheepshead Bay
$3,000
2 FM | 2 BR | 1.5 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Revived Residential
2 BR at 2652 EAST 18TH STREET, #PH6A

RLS

2652 EAST 18TH STREET, #PH6A
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$835,000
2 BR | 2 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass
1 BR at 3203 NOSTRAND AVENUE, #6J

RLS

3203 NOSTRAND AVENUE, #6J
Coop • Sheepshead Bay
$263,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
1 BR at 2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #2D

RLS

2654 EAST 18TH STREET, #2D
Condo • Sheepshead Bay
$460,000
1 BR | 1 BT

Listing Courtesy Of Compass

Current Sales (33)

Size	Starting from	Listings Count	Avg. $/Ft²	DOM
Studio	$220.0K	1	-	76
1 BR	$190.0K	11	$531	224
2 BR	$230.0K	16	$637	179
3 BR	$350.0K	4	$636	166

$451

Avg. Price/SqFt.

Prices Trend (2012-2024)

All Sizes

Studio

1 BR

2 BR

3 BR